ABOUT US
[387][401] I rather conclude
[417][426] that there is a linkage
[426][444] although it's obviously not proven
[447][460] at the present time
[485][501] we have eaten
[510][523] somewhere in the region of
[523][548] 3/4 of a million infected cattle
[551][570] fortunately the vast vast majority
[572][591] those would be early stage incubation but
[591][609] but some many thousands
[611][633] will have been near end stage um
[633][647] incubation and therefore
[652][665] high infectivity
[671][693] about 2/3 of them were eaten before
[695][713] the othel's man came into effect
[713][742] so we as a population in this country have had
[745][779] a high dose of this infectious disease
[780][793] this British being safety
[795][810] absolutely it always has been
[813][829] have no doubt about that at all
[831][841] even throughout the
[841][856] the worst of BSA
[856][881] you would still insist that British beef was safe
[896][924] I would be perfectly happy the British beef was safe
[924][929] and it was
[929][945] important to me because I live in the country
[945][959] my family live in the country
[959][974] my grandchildren live in the country
[974][993] and I have no concern about the health
[993][1005] from beef itself
[1010][1031] what is true is that historically
[1031][1052] even before the disease was recognized
[1054][1077] there would be some parts of cattle going into the food
[1077][1099] jam particularly from the central nervous system
[1103][1122] which could well have carried infectivity
[1122][1129] but that's a very
[1129][1148] different thing than talking about the safety of beef
[1148][1161] all the evidence is
[1163][1196] that the agents which cause these diseases
[1196][1220] do not appear in the muscle in any species
[1223][1253] I'm Brick Lumi on the
[1257][1275] transmission of C J D
[1275][1303] of B S E to humans
[1309][1317] and
[1325][1358] it seems to me that it's much better to be
[1359][1384] gloomy at the stage because um
[1388][1406] very often in these health matters
[1410][1445] although you can be too extreme um
[1453][1480] it is very dangerous to be complacent
[1503][1519] for farmer Neil Manning
[1519][1539] there are more pressing issues than the race
[1539][1550] to discover the linker
[1550][1578] otherwise between BSE and CJD
[1584][1607] like most British dairy and beef farmers
[1607][1630] he's too many cows on his farm
[1631][1659] as part of the government's measures against BSE
[1662][1691] over half a million cows aged over 30 months
[1691][1707] have been pulled since May
[1714][1721] but the sheer
[1721][1747] volume has created a blockage in the system
[1748][1774] and cows that are still destined to be slaughtered
[1774][1787] under the 30 month cull
[1787][1805] must remain on the farms
[1808][1828] cattle like these barren cows
[1828][1855] at the end of their productive lives as milkers
[1858][1875] the problem is across nationwide
[1875][1888] everybody's got these barrens
[1896][1921] in a week or 2 we'll start housing these cows and
[1921][1937] we just about have got room
[1937][1958] but they're gonna be tight and
[1959][1975] we don't want to look after a cat like that
[1975][1981] we want them
[1981][1996] you know we like plenty of space so I cattle
[1996][2004] we don't want them
[2004][2037] crammed in some problems I know haven't got space and
[2041][2057] after they haven't got the food when when
[2057][2078] when it comes to feeding and during the winter
[2078][2095] because they're all still eating a great deal
[2098][2107] um as you can see
[2107][2125] we're getting a little bit shorter grass and
[2129][2139] it's more mouse savine
[2139][2158] I just don't want the catelier they want to go
[2182][2194] so when Douglas Hogged
[2194][2217] the embattled British Minister of Agriculture
[2217][2237] visited a dairy farm in Lancashire
[2237][2247] in the north of England
[2247][2275] he could expect frustration from the farmers he met
[2278][2303] a further BSE colors what Europe wants
[2304][2327] so these farmers are expecting more problems
[2327][2360] so just a tremendous backlog of animals waiting to go
[2364][2372] and how in f
[2383][2405] they're going to cope when they start this
[2406][2427] extra core of all these cool hearts
[2431][2439] I think
[2445][2455] that is not going to happen
[2455][2474] if it happened at all in the near future
[2481][2497] we've put that right back
[2499][2521] and I don't think you should expect to see
[2522][2535] any substantial
[2546][2570] Carl anyway in their future
[2577][2587] well that's a good thing
[2588][2607] so you won't have to cope with that within
[2608][2618] the first number future
[2641][2665] one very good reason they'll not be a new
[2665][2677] colony near future
[2677][2686] is that the system
[2686][2713] for disposing of dead cows is overloaded
[2716][2743] the carcasses of the cars slaughtered in the Oprah 39
[2743][2763] called the first and so far the only
[2763][2781] BSC inspired column Britain
[2782][2794] are stained yellow
[2794][2811] and transported to one of Britain's
[2811][2830] licensed rendering plants
[2840][2863] it's here rather than the habitwires
[2863][2881] that the blockage is so acute
[2881][2896] nationwide up to 15
[2899][2925] 000 cows a week are currently being processed
[2926][2947] putting a strain on the renver's normal work
[2947][2958] in capacity
[2966][2977] to relieve the pressure
[2977][2990] the Ministry of Agriculture
[2990][3010] plans to find additional coal storage
[3010][3019] for the cows that have
[3019][3028] already been slaughtered
[3028][3039] in the abattwise
[3040][3047] at least
[3047][3074] 4 grain warehouses are currently being converted
[3074][3095] to stockpile the carcasses that are waiting for
[3095][3103] rendering
[3105][3125] but with nearly half a million cows line
[3125][3137] idly on the farms
[3138][3157] clearly these measures aren't enough
[3184][3210] the choke point has been the renderers
[3211][3239] and by reducing the proportion of the carcass
[3239][3254] that has to be rendered
[3255][3283] and by taking on more Kell storage facilities
[3284][3301] we can increase the screw point
[3308][3341] weekly we hoped up to around 55 000
[3344][3364] and so we would hope to be able to clear
[3364][3371] the Bachelon by
[3371][3380] around Christmas
[3382][3393] that is our hope
[3404][3412] but the whole
[3412][3440] coal issue has become a political battlefield
[3441][3461] where anti European politicians in
[3461][3479] Britain's governing Conservative Party
[3479][3497] can and probably would
[3497][3518] defeat the extended coal policy
[3518][3531] in the House of Commons
[3535][3558] they and a large number of their constituents
[3558][3584] believe the European Union is ignoring the
[3584][3611] scientific rationality of the BSE issue
[3611][3620] instead
[3620][3651] threatening Britain's multi billion pint beef industry
[3651][3676] for the benefit of its other member states
[3679][3719] I think as time goes by one finds a cause for concern
[3720][3738] as to what the colors about
[3738][3757] and if it's about appeasing Europe
[3757][3782] and not about scientific evidence and fagged
[3783][3803] then I would be very very concerned
[3803][3816] about the implications of that
[3816][3824] and I would take that
[3824][3843] into account in deciding how I voted
[3849][3861] it's here at Oxford
[3861][3891] Center for the Epidemiology of Infectious Disease
[3891][3911] that the government find the scientific evidence
[3911][3928] that wanted and needed to hear
[3928][3957] to make a no extended cult policies and reasonable
[3961][3983] professor Royanderson and his research team
[3983][4013] looked at the epidemiology of BSE and capital
[4015][4050] the peak of infection in the British herd was in 1992
[4053][4063] when over 36
[4063][4092] 000 cows were found to be infected with BSE
[4094][4123] since then the disease has been in steady declined
[4125][4131] the research
[4131][4160] shows that the trend is inclined to continue downwards
[4160][4195] with the British herd being clear of BSE by 2001
[4197][4212] with the exception of a trickle of
[4212][4239] cases that will continue for an indeterminate time
[4242][4258] but does Professor Andersen believe
[4258][4269] the results of his work
[4269][4295] justify the no extended cold policy
[4306][4321] my own view is you should put the
[4321][4345] public health and safety issues first
[4351][4377] and if you're convinced there should be
[4385][4416] there is an association between BSE and the new
[4416][4428] CJD variant
[4436][4466] then it would be desirable to take down
[4467][4493] the BSE epidemic as quickly as possible
[4497][4521] within given economic bounds
[4527][4554] so what we did in our analysis
[4555][4589] we created a scientific framework for the analysis
[4601][4646] and then analyzed verse options with different economic
[4650][4683] implications and epidemiological implications
[4685][4721] and we listed the effect of each of these policies
[4723][4733] and I believe
[4736][4748] that's our role
[4752][4766] it is government's role
[4767][4804] to decide which policy wants to put in place
[4829][4851] in response to Professor Andersen study
[4851][4880] the government told farmers and Europe that whilst
[4880][4894] cows over 30 months would
[4894][4921] continue to be removed from the human food chain
[4921][4942] and cold over a period of time
[4945][4970] the extended coal agreed in Florence in June
[4970][4977] which was to
[4977][5015] identify and slaughter immediately 147,000 cows
[5015][5023] over 30 months
[5023][5043] from herds where BSE had occurred
[5045][5060] would not take place
[5064][5081] so the government's interpretation of
[5081][5095] Professor Andersen's work
[5096][5113] is that a more effective coal
[5113][5144] which would reduce an unquantifiable BSE risk
[5145][5174] the health of the Republic could cost too much
[5175][5193] many 10s of millions of crimes
[5193][5206] more than the British government
[5206][5219] of the large percent of the
[5242][5269] it appears that only when the risk is better understood
[5269][5287] where further action be taken
[5297][5324] better understanding the risk is on the agenda
[5324][5344] at the University of Wills
[5354][5381] at this meeting experts discuss the crisis
[5381][5391] amongst the speakers
[5391][5402] professor John Bryn
[5402][5429] Owen of the School of Agricultural Sciences
[5433][5457] my thesis today is that we should
[5457][5476] give the highest priority
[5477][5491] to getting rid
[5493][5517] radicate and B S E
[5519][5545] We can't reject this human transfer
[5546][5581] particularly because it looks like
[5585][5593] the
[5593][5627] same reasons as in the B S E
[5633][5676] it also is quite significant that the French
[5677][5703] people have been able to transfer
[5708][5739] BSE to monkeys and they've got the same
[5744][5773] sort of lesions as in humans
[5801][5823] you may say that it hasn't been proved
[5825][5841] hasn't been proved directly
[5847][5864] but a scientist I think
[5876][5903] seeing no other possibility at this stage
[5905][5941] would only reject that hypothesis at very great peril
[5949][5964] professor John Brunoan is
[5964][5989] not alone in believing that the British Government has
[5989][5997] not encouraged
[5997][6012] enough scientific research
[6012][6041] to assess the risks of VSE to public health
[6055][6075] I think where they have fallen down
[6075][6098] is that they haven't taken notice
[6104][6154] so as we can see properly of a wider base of advice
[6157][6166] in fact
[6180][6189] there has been
[6197][6218] really very little um
[6222][6250] account taken off some of the people who've
[6252][6267] rather contrary views
[6269][6288] and in fact in retrospect
[6289][6305] some of those views have been
[6306][6321] near at the Mark than the
[6323][6335] rather small
[6337][6368] and rather stable group of scientists that have been
[6370][6393] seemingly advising the government
[6402][6419] perhaps inevitably the
[6419][6446] Internet has become involved in the quest of those
[6446][6475] scientists ignored by government policy makers
[6475][6485] to further the
[6486][6501] understanding of the issues involved
[6501][6521] by communicating to whoever will listen
[6530][6557] behind this Internet page is Dr
[6557][6568] Stephen Dealer
[6569][6605] a senior microbiologist who spent the last 7 years
[6606][6632] searching for the truth about BSE
[6661][6684] Dr Dealer has taken on the role
[6684][6723] of being the never popular messenger of bad news
[6761][6784] this is a fatal disease with no method of treatment
[6784][6799] no method of diagnosis
[6800][6818] pass from one species to another
[6818][6835] by eating infected food
[6837][6845] and
[6851][6874] it is not destroyed by cooking
[6878][6903] you don't wait to see if humans start to die
[6905][6930] you get ready with the research and
[6933][6953] the scientists realize this
[6959][6979] and I I mean
[6983][7001] France is all research I've done I'm not
[7001][7019] don't get any funding for it at all
[7024][7038] all the research done by
[7045][7072] various groups got no funding for a long time
[7075][7085] and
[7097][7113] it was because they weren't doing the things
[7113][7125] that the Ministry of Agriculture wanted
[7125][7159] to find out as far as I can see I mean that's the way
[7165][7174] the way it appeared
[7194][7216] there's some relief in Britain that at last
[7216][7223] there's a live
[7223][7247] test for Bsc and CJD
[7250][7259] although it will only
[7259][7280] identify the disease in late stages
[7280][7303] when the patient's brain has already been damaged
[7304][7330] it will be useful in diagnosis and further
[7330][7347] understanding of the disease
[7353][7383] but the tests been developed simultaneously in America
[7383][7408] and Germany although Britain has more to
[7408][7425] gain than any other country from these
[7425][7439] scientific developments
[7439][7465] its research programs lagged behind
[7497][7531] now another country offers its insights into BSE
[7534][7564] in Iceland scientists have been studying Scrapey
[7564][7585] the BSE like disease and sheep
[7586][7613] scrape has been known for about 200 years
[7613][7643] and much of what we know about BSE derives from work
[7643][7669] on Scrapey 20 years ago
[7669][7694] in a program to eradicate scraping in Iceland
[7695][7718] herds of infected sheep were cold
[7718][7745] and the land restocked with uninfected sheep
[7745][7773] from areas known to be free of the disease
[7773][7785] the sheep weren't fed
[7785][7814] any animal feed other the natural grass and hay
[7815][7843] yet they too became infected with scraping
[7855][7868] wondery stalking
[7871][7903] even on farms that had been free
[7909][7927] or sheep for 3 years
[7929][7947] it tended to recur
[7947][7961] on some farms
[7965][7978] and this provoked
[7979][7990] idea that
[7992][8004] there might be some
[8006][8031] vector in the surrounding that keeps
[8035][8066] infectivity around on the premises
[8073][8082] and
[8087][8092] one
[8092][8119] idea that this might be haymites
[8125][8136] and there are
[8137][8163] some preliminary results
[8166][8193] that indicate that teammates may play
[8194][8201] a role
[8201][8245] but these are just very preliminary and
[8253][8287] and we are planning to problem them closer up
[8293][8320] and there are some person questions that these
[8331][8357] restarts on the hemits arises
[8362][8389] especially pretending to the species barrier
[8396][8410] since scrape is endemic
[8410][8431] in sheep flocks in certain countries
[8431][8441] such as Britain
[8445][8474] that suggests there is some form
[8477][8500] perhaps of horizontal transmission
[8507][8515] and
[8520][8551] the precise mode of that is uncertain at present
[8551][8580] whether from studies in Iceland or studies from the UK
[8587][8614] so that does leave the nagging doubt in your mind that
[8617][8625] there may be
[8625][8653] a component of horizontal transmission in Bsc
[8661][8688] the only argument I can put you at the moment is we've
[8689][8699] searched desperately
[8699][8719] for it in the epidemiological data
[8725][8742] and in particular we've looked
[8743][8769] the rapid phase of decay in this epidemic
[8770][8793] over the last 5 years 4 years
[8799][8825] and at present we can find no
[8829][8854] evidence from the experimental studies
[8855][8866] or evidence
[8866][8895] from the epidemiological database of its presence
[8898][8920] that doesn't absolutely argue it's not there
[8921][8943] it's just we can't detect it at present
[8950][8970] the Lancet is one of the world's leading
[8970][8986] medical science journals
[8987][9002] it's played a major role
[9002][9009] in reporting
[9009][9035] the significant developments in the research on BSC
[9035][9047] and CJD
[9048][9075] including the findings from Iceland and the New Life
[9075][9093] Test on CJD in America
[9098][9111] in a recent editorial
[9111][9132] the Lancet launched a scathing attack
[9132][9155] on the way the government has handled the research
[9155][9175] into CJD and BSE
[9191][9209] the UK government's policies have
[9209][9221] LED to the sacrifice of
[9221][9236] thousands of healthy cattle
[9237][9251] they've also threatened the belief
[9251][9274] that UK scientists can respond adequately
[9274][9287] to a new infectious risk
[9287][9293] it's not that
[9293][9306] difficult to get government
[9306][9323] funding for something that has got
[9330][9359] the possibility of an immediate payback in votes
[9359][9373] to be cynical about it
[9378][9390] it's not that difficult to get
[9397][9419] funding from pharmaceutical companies
[9426][9435] if the
[9435][9456] research you're doing is going to end up with a better
[9456][9479] pill which they can sell and make a profit at all
[9491][9525] when it comes to solving a very difficult
[9526][9547] complicated problem like
[9549][9578] spongy foreign careful officers Bsc and CJD
[9593][9639] there is no real go oriented
[9650][9662] thing about it at all
[9685][9697] the gun was elect and
[9697][9709] presumably to put money
[9709][9732] into a problem they couldn't see an easy solution to
[9734][9749] and couldn't see votes in
[9763][9787] and I think this is tragedic we make sure we do
[9787][9814] professor Jeffrey Almond is a member of the government
[9814][9841] spongy form in Kaffalapathy Advisory Committee
[9841][9868] say I a relatively recent recruit
[9869][9878] he was one of 3
[9878][9892] members who played a major
[9892][9909] part in the British government's announcement
[9909][9921] on March the 20th
[9921][9944] that there could be a link between BSE
[9944][9964] and the human equivalent CJD
[9965][9984] yes there was a point that we could have done
[9984][9992] more in this area
[9992][10006] we could have spent more money
[10010][10023] but you can't just focus
[10023][10025] all
[10025][10048] your money in one area and let the rest of the science
[10048][10057] base go you
[10057][10070] you need to have
[10071][10083] people of the right caliber
[10083][10115] and that means a proper funding for the science base
[10115][10135] generally it's not just a message for
[10135][10152] for our government it's a message for
[10154][10166] governments all around the world
[10166][10174] there has been
[10179][10205] over the last sort of decade a tightening
[10205][10217] in many countries on
[10217][10243] on the amount of money spent on basic scientific
[10243][10255] research and I think
[10258][10283] you know we're in a very scientific and technological
[10284][10300] age and if we let that slip
[10305][10342] the next generation of cures of
[10343][10361] technological advances and so on
[10363][10375] will not be forthcoming
[10375][10395] because they're all based on basic science
[10402][10430] in his almost anonymous offices in the suburbs of
[10430][10441] London the Assistant
[10441][10444] Chief
[10444][10466] Veterinary Officer at the Ministry of Agriculture
[10466][10487] has heard all the criticisms before
[10488][10518] but his message to Europe remains simple and constant
[10530][10545] not asking people to do anything
[10545][10558] other than to look
[10566][10579] at the
[10588][10604] scientific evidence
[10614][10626] without prejudice
[10631][10656] to look at that evidence to look at the
[10660][10687] control measures which have been put in place
[10689][10703] in the United Kingdom
[10709][10723] to look at the effect of those
[10723][10748] control measures in control in the epidemic
[10753][10765] and to conclude
[10766][10789] as all the independent scientists
[10789][10810] working in the field in this country have done
[10816][10829] has has been supported by the
[10829][10852] Scientific Betany Committee of the Commission has
[10852][10881] has been supported by the World Health Organization
[10883][10913] that the measures which have been put in place
[10917][10941] to control the disease and animals
[10941][10956] to protect public health
[10957][10979] of both appropriate and adequate
[11011][11026] back on the farms of Britain
[11026][11046] the pressure is too much to endure
[11046][11062] the extra mounts to feed the
[11062][11083] like a space to protect them during the winter
[11083][11109] and all this on top of the collapsed capital market
[11109][11141] at least 3 farming suicides are linked to the BSE
[11141][11149] crisis
[11155][11175] and the price of you that the young stuck has dropped
[11191][11215] and the bank are threatening to to withdraw the lawn
[11217][11232] to help others farmers left
[11234][11242] different persuades
[11242][11271] and rural help lines for farmers
[11273][11282] as the crisis that we
[11283][11288] have
[11288][11310] more and more stress lines are opening all
[11311][11338] over him I'll try and get a stay of execution
[11342][11358] it's the anger
[11367][11392] and the frustration that they've had
[11394][11400] in
[11400][11429] having the accusations that they are responsible for
[11429][11439] some dreadful disease
[11439][11450] which is going to wipe out
[11450][11476] half mankind and they cannot see that
[11476][11499] and they do not believe that that is the case
[11536][11551] we've got to make sure
[11551][11575] that the scientists that are working on the program
[11575][11591] are working flat out
[11592][11612] for the sake really of a mankind
[11617][11655] not really on what suits a political end
[11659][11681] from some country or some government
[11689][11699] don't have it up
[12099][12125] the more we know the more we need to know
[12126][12149] for the people of Britain and the rest of Europe
[12149][12161] the waiting goes on
[12163][12191] fearing the worst hoping for the best
[12196][12220] this is Ron Mccullough for TVA Vandar
[12233][12264] Ron Mccullough for ORF Television United Kingdom

